You have been charged with a white collar crime, and are facing a potentially lengthy prison sentence if convicted, significant legal fees to defend yourself, and the prospect of a trial where your “dirty laundry,” in terms of the charges against you, will be aired in public. Then you receive a plea offer from the prosecutors in which the Government agrees to drop some of the charges against you in exchange for a guilty plea. What should you take into consideration when deciding whether or not to accept the plea offer (recognizing that no two cases are exactly alike)?
Reasons to Consider Not Accepting a Plea Offer:
You’re innocent, and the prosecutors have it all wrong. You want to be exonerated at trial. If you go to a trial, you may be found not guilty. If the prosecutors have a weak case, it may fall apart during trial. And any guilty verdict must be unanimous, often not an easy task. Also remember that there are many adverse consequences to being a convicted felon. You’re a felon for life. It is much more difficult to get a job, as most job applications ask whether you’ve been convicted of a felony. You can’t vote. You will likely be placed on probation for up to 3 years, have to report to a Probation Officer, and have a number of restrictions placed on you.
Reasons to Consider Accepting a Plea Offer:
First and foremost, you will almost certainly be able to plead guilty to lesser charges if you accept a plea offer, and will therefore ultimately receive a lesser sentence than you would have received if you had gone to trial and were found guilty. If you are able to cooperate, your sentence may be reduced even further. In fact, you may not receive any jail or federal prison time at all, although that, of course, will depend entirely on the facts and circumstances of your particular case. Your fines and penalties may also be reduced considerably.
In a federal case, where the courts are required to consider the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, if you plead guilty you will receive credit because both the Government and the courts will be able to conserve their resources. Moreover, significant cooperation could earn you a 5K letter from the Government, in which the Government asks the court to sentence you to a term of imprisonment below the Guidelines range, possibly significantly below the range.
Finally, of course, to plead guilty you must be guilty. At your plea hearing, the court will ask the necessary questions to ensure that your guilty plea is both voluntary and intelligent, that you actually committed the crime, and that you recognize that you are waiving your Constitutional rights to a jury trial, to confront the witnesses against you, and to remain silent without the prosecutor being able to comment on your failure to testify.
The vast majority of criminal cases do not go to trial, but rather, are resolved by plea agreements and guilty pleas. In deciding whether or not to accept a guilty plea, a defendant must carefully balance the pros and cons of a plea.
- Am I guilty?
- What are the chances of success at trial, that is, a not guilty verdict on all courts?
- How much risk am I willing to take?
- What will it cost me to try the case?
- How will the publicity of a case, if any, affect both myself and my family?
It is only after carefully considering questions such as these that a defendant can make an informed decision on whether or not to plead guilty. And remember, once you plead, be prepared to live with the consequences, as it is usually very difficult to set aside your plea.
Finally, hiring the right criminal defense lawyer is also very important. Hire an experienced white collar criminal defense attorney who you are comfortable with, and who can help guide you through the process as you consider the difficult decision of whether to plead guilty or not. If you have questions about the legal process, feel free to reach out.
Prepare For Your Federal Sentencing Hearing: If you truly want to prepare for your federal sentencing this blog will help you. I say "truly" because our experience (our team, including Shon Hopwood and Michael Santos, have more than 50 years combined experience) tells...
Why Innocent White Collar Defendants Plead Guilty You are absolutely one of the many white collar defendants who are innocent but pleaded guilty. Let me say it again. You (along with many other white collar defendants) are 100% innocent of whatever the government says...
Presentence Investigation Report: It's Sunday March 8th. I decided to write this blog after receiving a message from a white-collar defendant. The defendant told me his lawyer told him to show up to his presentence interview with "nothing". I told him he was making a...
Financial Tips for Federal Prisoners This blog is for the white collar professional who finds himself heading to a federal prison camp or is already in a federal prison camp. As my partners, Michael Santos & Shon Hopwood, prove just because you are in federal prison...
3 Life Lessons I Learned From Running in Federal Prison When I was sentenced to 18 months at the Taft Federal Prison Camp, I knew that I would have plenty of free time to get back in shape. In fact, getting in shape and maybe learning Spanish were really the only two...
Michael: So, I'm really excited to be speaking with my friend, and partner, and colleague, Justin Paperny about federal prison planning. Obviously, all of you know him, because if you're on this section you're a member of our program. I just wanted to ask Justin a few...