After Release Reflections: Why I Once Wanted to Stay in Prison Longer

A close friend of mine is going to prison soon. He has a young son, and since he’ll miss Halloween, our block decided to celebrate early. Costumes, candy, and kids running through the yard.

While getting dressed, I thought about the book I just finished—After the Fall. In chapter one, I describe a moment in prison when I told my friend Sam I was turning down the halfway house. I wanted to stay longer.

It sounds irrational, even to me now. Before sentencing, I was desperate to avoid prison. But a few months in, I started saying, I can do a few more months here.

The Disconnect No One Expects

Before prison, all I could think about was getting through it as fast as possible. Every conversation, every plan, was built around the question: How do I get home sooner?

Then you get inside, and something changes. The outside world keeps spinning, but your world slows down. You start building a routine—reading, writing, working out, thinking. You find a rhythm that gives the day structure.

That’s what happened to me. I found stability in the predictability. Meals at the same time. Walks at the same time. Reading after count. For the first time in years, I could think clearly.

So when the chance came to leave for the halfway house, I hesitated. Leaving meant starting over again—new people, new rules, more uncertainty. Inside, I had finally built something I understood.

Why I Wanted to Stay

It wasn’t about loving prison. It was about avoiding chaos. The camp was uncomfortable, but it was consistent. The halfway house, from what I’d heard, was unpredictable—crowded, loud, full of restrictions that made it hard to work or plan ahead.

I thought staying three more months would give me more time to prepare. To write. To finish projects. I told myself it was strategic.

Sam looked at me like I’d lost my mind.
He said, “All you wanted was to get out. Now you want to stay?”

He was right to be confused. I had gone from dreading prison to protecting the structure it gave me.

The Moment of Regret

In the end, I did go to the halfway house. My first day there, I regretted it immediately. The noise, the tension, the lack of privacy—it felt like starting from zero. I missed the focus I had in the camp.

But that regret taught me something important: I wasn’t really missing prison. I was missing the discipline and routine that prison had forced me to build.

The lesson came later. Discipline doesn’t belong to a place. It belongs to a person.

What These After Release Reflections Mean

If you’re getting ready to leave prison, or if someone you care about is, the hardest part isn’t the transition itself. It’s realizing that the structure that kept you stable won’t exist anymore.

People think release means freedom. It does, but it also means exposure. No one is making you get up at 5 a.m. No one is checking if you wrote or exercised. You have to create your own accountability, every day, without applause.

Here’s what I tell clients and friends:

  1. Write down the daily schedule that worked for you in prison. Don’t abandon it. Adjust it for life outside.
  2. Define one measurable goal for the first month home. Not ten—just one you can document.
  3. Keep track of your progress in writing. Judges, probation officers, and employers care about evidence, not claims.
  4. Avoid the trap of comparison. Everyone’s timeline looks different. Measure against effort, not outcome.

Those small steps matter more than any speech about second chances.

FAQ

Q: Why would anyone want to stay in prison longer?
A: It’s not about comfort—it’s about control over a predictable routine. Many people fear losing that structure when they reenter society.

Q: What’s the key lesson from this experience?
A: Discipline and consistency can’t depend on your environment. They have to travel with you.

Q: How can someone prepare before release?
A: Create a written record of your daily progress now. That record becomes proof that you’re serious about change.

If you or someone you care about is preparing for release and unsure how to stay productive, join our next webinar or schedule a personal call. We’ll review how others built documentation that proved they were ready for the next phase.

Justin Paperny

Read Our New York Times Article

And Lessons From Prison, Free!

This is a staging environment