HomeRisks of Rejecting a Plea Agreement

Risks of Rejecting a Plea Agreement

Choosing whether to accept or reject a plea agreement is one of the most critical decisions a defendant will face in the criminal justice system. While rejecting a plea bargain may feel like an act of principle or a chance to prove innocence, it’s essential to understand the potential consequences, including the Risks of Rejecting a Plea Agreement. Trials involve inherent risks—criminal defendants who reject a plea offer could face more severe outcomes if they lose at a jury trial.

I’m Justin Paperny, and I’ve witnessed firsthand how these decisions can determine the future of individuals charged with felony offenses or misdemeanor offenses. In this article, I’ll discuss the risks of rejecting a plea deal, when it might make sense to proceed to a full trial, and how to approach this decision strategically.

1. The Risk of Harsher Penalties

One of the biggest risks of rejecting a plea agreement is facing harsher penalties if convicted at trial. Prosecutors often use different types of plea bargains—such as charge bargaining or sentence bargaining—to incentivize defendants to avoid trial, offering reduced criminal charges or a lighter sentence.

Trial Penalty

  • Defendants who go to trial and lose often receive sentences that are significantly more severe than those discussed during plea negotiations under the Sentencing Guidelines.
  • Example: A defendant offered a plea deal for 3 years in prison might face a maximum penalty of 10 years or more if convicted at trial, depending on the applicable state law or federal law.

Why This Happens

  • Trials consume time and resources, so the district attorney or prosecution’s case team may push for harsher sentences as a deterrent to others who might reject plea deals.
  • Judges sometimes impose a “trial penalty,” believing a defendant who rejects a plea agreement is unwilling to accept responsibility.

2. Increased Costs and Stress

Trials can be lengthy, complex, and expensive. Rejecting a plea bargain often means committing to a drawn-out legal battle involving pretrial motions, court hearings, potential police interrogations, and a public trial. This can take a significant toll on your finances, mental health, and personal relationships.

Financial Costs

  • Preparing for trial can require hiring expert witnesses, investigating additional evidence, and examining pretrial issues. Legal fees for quality legal representation—a criminal defense lawyer or broader legal counsel—can escalate quickly.
  • Specific cases, such as wire fraud charges or federal cases, may require specialized defense strategies and more intensive preparation.

Emotional Strain

  • The uncertainty of a trial outcome, combined with public scrutiny during the proceedings, can create substantial anxiety.
  • Friends and family also face the stress of seeing a loved one navigate the criminal justice system, often in a high-stakes environment.

3. Loss of Control Over the Outcome

A plea offer provides a degree of predictability and sometimes includes sentencing recommendations or a particular sentence range. By rejecting a plea and opting for a jury trial, you place your future in the hands of a trial court, where the verdict can be unpredictable.

Uncertain Jury Decisions

  • Jurors must weigh the prosecution’s case against the defense’s presentation of such evidence. Even strong defenses can falter if the prosecution establishes proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
  • Judges have more discretion when determining a sentence post-trial. A presiding judge might impose mandatory minimum sentences or conditions more severe than those in the original plea negotiations.

Limited Input in Sentencing

  • In a plea agreement—often part of a plea bargaining process—prosecutors and defense counsel can negotiate a sentence recommendation or dismissal of other charges.
  • After a trial, a trial judge follows the applicable Sentencing Guidelines or state law, which may result in a harsher sentence if the defendant is found guilty.

4. Collateral Consequences of a Public Trial

Rejecting a plea agreement often means taking the stand in a public trial. This can attract significant media attention, especially in high-profile or Federal Criminal Cases. The public disclosure of the factual basis for the charges, witness testimony, and pretrial hearing details can have lasting reputational consequences.

Public Disclosure

  • Information that might have remained confidential during plea negotiations may become part of the public record, including personal details presented as evidence.
  • This exposure can damage your career prospects and community standing, even if you’re ultimately acquitted.

Impact on Career and Relationships

  • A criminal record or association with criminal offenses can hinder employment, financial opportunities, and personal relationships.
  • Even innocent defendants risk reputational harm simply by being on trial, as not everyone understands the presumption of innocence or the burden of proof standard.

When Rejecting a Plea Deal Might Make Sense

Though there are clear risks of rejecting a plea agreement, there are valid reasons and situations where going to trial could be in your best interest:

  • Weak Evidence: If the prosecution’s case heavily relies on circumstantial evidence or lacks a solid factual basis, a trial may increase the chances of an acquittal or lesser charge.
  • High-Stakes Plea Offers: If the plea offer is nearly as severe as what you might face after a conviction, taking your constitutional right to a fair trial could be a calculated risk.
  • Principle or Innocence: Some defendants reject plea offers to challenge law enforcement’s actions, assert their Fourth Amendment or Sixth Amendment right, or clear their name if they genuinely did not commit the charged offense.

Example:
A defendant charged with multiple counts of fraud is offered a plea bargain requiring 15 years in prison. After consulting with a criminal defense lawyer, they discover that the government’s case is weak, relying on testimony from questionable witnesses and incomplete documentation. Since the potential sentence at trial might be comparable, they proceed to trial in the hope of charge reductions or an outright acquittal.

How to Make an Informed Decision

Deciding whether to accept or reject a plea agreement requires meticulous thought, a sound legal strategy, and strong communication with legal counsel.

  1. Assess the Government’s Case
    • Review the evidence, credibility of witnesses, and possible defenses with your attorney. Consider whether a pretrial motion to suppress certain evidence or a preliminary hearing might reduce charges.
  2. Understand the Risks
    • Compare the plea agreement terms, including any suggested sentence bargaining or lesser sentence, with the potential trial outcome. Always factor in mandatory minimum sentences or maximum penalties.
  3. Evaluate Your Priorities
    • Weigh the financial, emotional, and reputational costs of going to trial. Determine if the possibility of a direct appeal or judicial review is worth the uncertainty.
  4. Prepare for Either Outcome
    • Whether you accept a deal or reject a plea, build a strong mitigation strategy. Collect character references, demonstrate accountability, and gather evidence showing good cause for leniency.

A Real Story: Michael’s Decision to Reject a Plea Deal

Michael, a software developer, faced conspiracy charges related to wire fraud. The government’s plea agreement recommended 8 years. However, Michael and his criminal defense lawyer discovered several weaknesses in the prosecution’s case: unreliable witnesses, incomplete documentation, and questionable law enforcement procedures.

Despite recognizing the risks of rejecting a plea agreement, Michael believed he had valid reasons to pursue a full trial. After a rigorous defense and presenting a compelling counter-narrative, the jury found him guilty on a lesser charge. The presiding judge imposed a 5-year sentence—shorter than the original plea offer. Michael’s careful planning, strong representation, and willingness to present evidence in federal courts paid off, though it could easily have gone the other way.

Next Steps

In our next discussion, we’ll delve deeper into evaluating plea negotiations and exploring the plea bargaining process, including guidance on navigating pretrial hearing strategies and the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure.

If you’re considering rejecting a plea offer or need legal advice:

  1. Consult With Your Attorney – Request a free consultation or schedule a private meeting to discuss your defendant’s right to a public trial, potential dismissal of other charges, and possible negotiation process outcomes. Need help finding a great attorney, we can help. Find Your Top Lawyer Now.
  2. Understand the Consequences – Know the potential jail time, trial penalty, or charge reductions you might face.
  3. Seek Support – Join our next webinar, connect with others in similar situations, or secure robust legal representation to protect your constitutional rights.
  4. Schedule your Intro Call with a Mitigation Expert or call/text us at 949-799-3277 to speak with our team immediately.

By thoroughly evaluating the prosecution’s evidence, the likelihood of a fair trial, and the ramifications of rejecting a plea deal, you can make an informed decision about whether to accept a particular sentence recommendation or bring your case before a trial judge. Your future may depend on how well-prepared you are for this critical step in the legal system.

This is a staging environment