Skip to content
Request a Call
Back to the Blog
Sentencing5 min read

Under Federal Investigation? What to Do Before Charges

FBI contacted me; preparing for a federal investigation; federal investigation before charges; how long do federal investigations take; help during a federal investigation.

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice · November 16, 2026

Share Article

Under Federal Investigation? Are You Making the Mistakes I Made?

When defense lawyer and former federal prosecutor Alex Little interviewed me on The Target Podcast, I told him how I responded when I suspected the FBI was listening to a phone call:

“I thought I could talk my way out of it.”

I kept talking. I lied. Then I continued giving half-truths to the lawyers I hired to help me.

I was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison. I earned a prison sentence through my conduct as a stockbroker. I also believe my response during the investigation contributed to a longer sentence than I needed to serve. I gave people more reasons to question me while doing little to explain what I had learned or how I was changing.

If you’re under federal investigation, are you doing any of those things? Are you telling your lawyer everything? Are you still calling people connected to the investigation because they make you feel better? Do you understand what could follow from those conversations?

Those were some of the questions Alex, his co-host Amy Nelson, and I explored in our interview. Alex has known me for years. We’ve also worked with the same person on a federal case, with Alex handling the legal representation and our team helping with preparation. He asked me about the decisions I made before prison and why I kept making them even after I had lawyers trying to help.

Watch the full interview with Alex Little and Amy Nelson on The Target Podcast.

I kept talking because I wanted the FBI to believe me

It was 7 a.m. on a Saturday in Calabasas. UBS had recently fired me and escorted me out of my Century City office. My former client, a hedge fund manager, called from his office instead of his usual cell phone with the 661 area code.

His voice sounded different and so did the questions. I suspected the call was being recorded and decided that was an opportunity. The FBI could listen while I explained that I was simply the broker executing trades. I hadn’t managed the money. I was younger than my senior partner. I had gone to UBS about the losses and commissions.

I was making my pitch to people I couldn’t see, whose investigation I didn’t understand. That caller would become my co-defendant.

Later, FBI agent Paul Bertrand arrived at my home with another agent and binders of documents. When I eventually sat down for an interview, I still thought I could explain things away.

“It’s one thing to say I don’t recall or I don’t know,” I said in the podcast. “It’s another thing to flat out lie, which is what I did.”

If investigators have contacted you, have you spoken with a federal criminal defense lawyer about how to respond? Have you told counsel about statements you’ve already made? I wanted agents to accept my version so badly that I kept adding to the problems my lawyers would have to address.

I hired good lawyers and denied them the full story

I told Alex and Amy why I lied: “I didn’t want to be viewed as a criminal.”

I liked the acknowledgment that came with working at Bear Stearns and UBS. After I was fired, I told my parents I had chosen to leave. My mother had worked as a paralegal for more than 30 years. She questioned why I would walk away from the career I had worked to build. I kept telling her my preferred version anyway.

I did the same with my lawyers. I wanted them to respect me, so I withheld information and blamed other people. Then, when things weren’t going well, I blamed the lawyers.

“So I had great lawyers,” I said during the interview. “They tried to help me.”

Alex and I discussed how hard it can be for someone who has enjoyed professional success to tell a lawyer the things they’re ashamed of. But I was paying for advice while leaving out information that could change that advice. My lawyers were trying to assess a case I wasn’t fully describing.

What are you leaving out? Is there a payment, email, meeting, or relationship you haven’t explained because you don’t want your lawyer to think differently of you?

“Like, if you think it’s bad, share it,” I said in the interview. I meant share it with your lawyer. Let counsel assess it. I had spent enough time deciding for myself what mattered, and my judgment had helped get me into the investigation.

I accepted reassurance instead of understanding the consequences

When investors began filing lawsuits, I hired a civil lawyer. I heard that UBS would eventually settle with them, and I felt better.

“What gave me comfort was UBS was going to scratch the check.”

That was what I wanted to hear. I hadn’t answered the question of my own criminal exposure. I also kept talking to my former senior partner because those conversations were familiar and comforting. We discussed keeping accounts at the firm and how I could continue receiving money from the business.

Other people were getting legal advice and responding to the government. I kept assuming we were a team.

Then time passed. I got my real estate license and began selling homes in Calabasas. No immediate arrest. No immediate sentencing. I started thinking the government had forgotten about me.

“I just figure they sort of forgot about me,” I admitted in the interview.

Do you know the status of your investigation, or are you drawing conclusions from the absence of news? Have you asked your lawyer about contact with former colleagues? Are you listening to advice, or looking for someone who will agree that you have nothing to worry about?

I had people trying to speak directly to me. I kept giving them excuses. As I explained in the podcast, “I told half truths and denials and excuses all the way until I surrendered to prison.”

That is how long I continued the behavior. I had years to respond differently.

What are you doing before your federal case reaches sentencing?

During the interview, Alex compared understanding the other side of a case to watching game tape. I played college baseball. I understood studying an opponent before a game, yet I had spent little time asking my lawyers how investigators would interpret my conduct.

I kept repeating that I hadn’t managed the hedge fund. I needed to understand why my actions as the broker could expose me to criminal charges. I needed to listen when my lawyers explained the possibility of prison. Instead, I kept acting surprised that prison was still possible.

By the time I was sentenced, I had done little to explain my conduct without excuses. I had also done little to document what I was doing differently. I believe that failure cost me time in prison. I can’t tell you what sentence a different response would have produced. I know I gave the court less to consider than I could have.

Later in the podcast, I described a man who copied Michael Santos’s message about helping people in prisons and jails. He was disappointed that the judge didn’t respond to his letter as he had expected.

“The problem is, you actually haven’t done any of that,” I explained.

He had borrowed the words without doing the work he described. I see the same risk when someone uses AI to produce a polished account of who they intend to become. What happens when the judge asks what they’ve actually done?

If you’re preparing a narrative with counsel, can you support what it says? Does it describe your decisions, your circumstances, and actions you’ve taken? Or have you collected language that sounds like something a judge would want to hear?

You may dispute the allegations against you. Preparing does not require you to accept them. Your lawyer should guide decisions about statements, defense, and any plea. But you can begin asking questions now about the process and what preparation fits your situation.

Speak with White Collar Advice early in an investigation

You can come to us while you’re under investigation. You don’t need to wait until you have a sentencing date and a letter due next week.

Bring the questions you’re struggling with. Tell us what you’ve been doing since you learned about the investigation. If you’ve been avoiding meetings, withholding information from counsel, or spending months assuming nothing will happen, we can discuss those decisions and help you identify questions to take to your lawyer.

When a personal narrative or release plan is part of our engagement, we interview you, ask follow-up questions, and help draft and edit the document. You confirm the facts. Your lawyer addresses legal positions and what should be submitted.

There are also free books, courses, and educational resources through Prison Professors Charitable Corporation, a separate nonprofit. As I said in the interview, “If you can use all of our free stuff and do it, do it. You don’t need to hire White Collar Advice.”

I needed someone to challenge me and help me apply what I was learning. “I needed a guide.”

We will never ask you to do what we have not done and documented.

Schedule a conversation with our team. Tell us where you are in the investigation, whether you have counsel, and what you’ve done to prepare so far.

Justin Paperny

Written by

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice