Skip to content
Request a Call
Back to the Blog
Sentencing5 min read

What Happens If You Lie to the FBI? I Did, and Paid for It

Agent Paul Bertrand asked if I remembered an email. I said no twice. Then he handed it to me. How one answer changed my federal case. Part 16 of 30.

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice · Recently Published

Share Article

Lying to a federal agent is a separate federal crime under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, with a maximum of five years in most cases. In my case, it also ended my credibility with the government. Agent Paul Bertrand asked if I remembered an email. I said no twice, and then he handed it to me.

Would you read it again?

About a month after the FBI came to my house, my lawyer and I sat down with them. Special Agent Paul Bertrand asked the first question.

"Justin, do you remember a press release stating that your client Keith's hedge fund averaged 27 percent a year?"

I remembered. An email had come in at UBS from Keith's assistant, Patricia, announcing it. I'd read it and deleted it. I sat there thinking: they can prove it came in, but how can they prove I read it?

My lawyer had told me that if I wasn't sure, I should say I didn't recall. I wanted the meeting over. I'd lost my job. UBS was coming after my bonus. I felt like I'd suffered enough.

"No, I don't."

He asked again. I said no again.

He gave me a look I'll never forget. Then he reached into one of the binders, pulled out a sheet, and handed it to me. It was an email from me to Keith. In it, I told him I'd enjoyed his press release about the 27 percent guaranteed return fund.

"Would you read it again? Because a couple of minutes ago I heard you say you didn't recall it."

I read it again. My lawyer ended the meeting. Outside, he told me I had just lied to federal agents.

Judge Bough told Michael that what a defendant tells probation in the presentence interview becomes evidence.

What to do this week

Write down the five questions you'd least want an agent, a prosecutor, or a probation officer to ask you. Write the true answer under each. Go over them with your lawyer before any meeting.

Book a free call.

Questions people ask

Is it safer to say "I don't recall"?

Only if it's true. Prepare with your lawyer before any interview, and if you aren't sure how to answer, ask to speak with counsel.

Can I correct a false statement I already made?

Talk to your lawyer immediately. Correcting the record is a legal decision with consequences, and it should go through counsel.

Related: Michael interviewed Judges Bough and Bennett for 14 Costly Errors That Lead to Longer Prison Sentences. Lying to agents is one of the fourteen. The book is free at whitecollaradvice.com.

Read next: Part 17: How Long After an FBI Interview Can You Be Indicted?

Written by

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice