Table of Contents
If you can, and your lawyer agrees, yes. Judge Stephen Bough has said restitution paid before sentencing, even a small amount, shows him a defendant started fixing the damage without waiting for an order. Before my case came apart, I stood at a chalkboard and allocated $3 million that no longer existed.
The chalkboard in Encino
Judge Bough once explained responsibility to us with a story about a child who breaks a neighbor's window. The child knocks on the door. He apologizes. He helps sweep up the glass, and he takes responsibility for the repair.
Keith called again. One of his old investors had concerns and wanted to meet the broker at UBS. Before the meeting, I checked the fund. It held less than a million dollars.
We met in an office on Ventura Boulevard in Encino. The investor was 88. He brought two advisors. One of them looked at me.
"Justin, do you think an 88-year-old investor should have $3 million in a basket of growth stocks?"
He believed he had $3 million in that fund. I said Keith managed the money. He asked again.
I said that if it were my money, at 88, I'd want something more conservative. Fixed income. Steady cash.
"I agree. Will you help us allocate the $3 million that remains, the way you just described?"
Every eye in the room was on me. I said sure, walked to the chalkboard, and divided up $3 million that did not exist.
Afterward I pulled Keith aside. The man's money had been gone for years, lost at Bear Stearns before Keith ever called me. Keith had been mailing him fake statements ever since.
I shook the advisors' hands on the way out.
What to do this week
Go back to the list you started in Part 7. Pick one person on it. Write a paragraph about what you took from them, using the real word.
Questions people ask
Does paying restitution early reduce a federal sentence?
Nobody can promise that. Judges Bough and Bennett have both told us early payments, even $50 a month, mean more to them than promises to pay later.
How do I pay restitution before I'm sentenced?
Through your lawyer, so the payments are documented and credited properly.
Related: David Moulder paid his restitution in full before his sentencing hearing. His guidelines said 48 to 60 months: Federal conspiracy sentencing guidelines
Read next: Part 11: What to Do When Your Employer Blames You for Fraud
Written by
Justin Paperny
Founder White Collar Advice




