Skip to content
Request a Call
Back to the Blog
Sentencing5 min read

White Collar Crime Investigation: What Can You Prepare?

Facing a white collar crime investigation? Learn what to ask your lawyer, how prosecutors evaluate your conduct, and which records to prepare before charges.

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice ยท November 17, 2026

Share Article

Under Federal Investigation? What Can You Show for Your Time?

You've learned that the federal government is investigating you. Perhaps the FBI visited your home, your employer received a subpoena, or your lawyer told you prosecutors consider you a target.

You hired a criminal defense lawyer. You've discussed the allegations, paid a retainer, and provided whatever information your attorney requested.

Now you're waiting.

Your lawyer may be communicating with prosecutors, reviewing financial transactions, and examining the government's evidence. Investigators may be interviewing people you worked with years ago, obtaining bank records, or studying communications you barely remember sending.

Where does that leave you?

Suppose the investigation continues for another 12 months. You may keep your job, lose your professional license, or face consequences that have nothing to do with a criminal conviction. You could also learn that prosecutors have decided against bringing charges.

During that period, what will you have accomplished?

Have you learned enough about the investigation to ask your lawyer useful questions? Have you addressed professional or financial problems that require attention? If your case eventually progresses to sentencing, will there be an accurate record of the work you've completed since learning about the allegations?

These questions deserve attention long before a federal judge becomes involved.

What Does the Government Know About You?

During a white collar crime investigation, prosecutors and federal agents may spend months examining transactions, interviewing witnesses, and studying business records.

Investigators might obtain emails from your former employer, statements from investors, or records documenting compensation you received.

They may compare those records with your explanations of what occurred.

Your criminal defense lawyer can help you understand what evidence the government appears to possess, what remains unknown, and which allegations can be challenged.

Begin by considering how prosecutors might describe the case.

If you're accused of wire fraud involving investors, what communications would the government use to support its allegations? Which financial transactions are central to the investigation? Does the government believe you personally made false representations, authorized them, or knowingly helped someone else?

Maybe the government's interpretation is wrong. Perhaps documents establish that you disclosed information prosecutors believe you concealed.

Those facts need to be examined carefully.

Someone who repeatedly tells a lawyer, "I never intended to hurt anyone," may still need to address records suggesting that investors received inaccurate information.

Someone maintaining innocence may need to identify evidence that prosecutors haven't considered.

In either situation, your lawyer needs a complete understanding of the relevant facts.

Are there emails, meetings, or financial arrangements you haven't discussed because you believe they make you look bad?

Are you describing what the records actually show or what you remember wanting to accomplish?

The answers can help counsel evaluate the government's allegations and the available defenses.

Do You Know Whether You're a Witness, Subject, or Target?

These terms are frequently used during federal investigations, but they describe different circumstances.

A witness may have information relevant to an investigation without being suspected of committing an offense.

A subject is someone whose conduct falls within the scope of a federal grand jury investigation.

A target is someone whom prosecutors or the grand jury believe substantial evidence links to a crime and whom the prosecutor considers a potential defendant.

Your status may change as the investigation progresses.

If you receive a federal target letter, review it carefully with your attorney. The letter may identify the nature of the investigation and explain your status.

You may also hear unfamiliar terms such as proffer, cooperation agreement, or immunity.

A proffer generally involves providing information to prosecutors under an agreement governing how that information may be used. It requires careful legal consideration.

Before participating in a voluntary interview or responding to a request for information, understand your attorney's advice and the potential consequences of the decision.

Federal investigators may already have obtained substantial evidence before they contact you. A statement you believe will resolve a misunderstanding could later be compared with documents and witness accounts.

The same concerns arise when communicating with people who may be involved in the investigation.

Your former business partner might have retained separate counsel. Your employer may be cooperating. Someone you've known for years could be providing information to prosecutors.

Do you know which communications your attorney wants you to avoid?

Do you understand your responsibilities for preserving emails, text messages, financial records, and other potentially relevant evidence?

Learning the answers should be among your earliest priorities.

Who Will Eventually Evaluate the Information About You?

During a federal investigation, different professionals have different responsibilities.

The prosecutor evaluates evidence and potential criminal charges. Your defense lawyer represents your interests and advises you about the legal decisions ahead.

If the case proceeds toward sentencing, a federal probation officer may prepare a presentence investigation report, and a judge will consider the relevant evidence and legal arguments.

What information will those people need?

The answer changes depending on the stage of your case.

A prosecutor examining allegations of securities fraud may focus on transactions, communications, financial benefits, and the person's knowledge or intent.

A probation officer preparing a presentence report may need information about employment, education, finances, family responsibilities, health, and the offense.

A judge considering sentencing may review the offense, the defendant's history, the applicable law, and information submitted by counsel.

You should understand these distinctions before preparing documents intended for anyone involved in the case.

A personal statement written while you're contesting allegations has different legal implications from a statement developed after a guilty plea.

An educational course completed during an investigation may later help establish your professional development. Whether that record belongs in a court submission depends on the circumstances and counsel's assessment.

The objective is to have accurate information available when the relevant decisions arise.

What Can You Create Before Anyone Files Criminal Charges?

Think about what may have changed since you first learned about the investigation.

Have you lost your job? Has your professional license been suspended? Are you facing financial difficulties because your legal expenses have increased?

Perhaps your employer has placed you on leave while conducting an internal investigation.

Some of these problems require attention regardless of whether prosecutors eventually bring charges.

A financial professional who can no longer work in securities might begin pursuing credentials in another industry.

A business owner might study accounting controls and compliance procedures, provided those activities are appropriate given the allegations and counsel's advice.

Someone who has experienced genuine problems with alcohol or other substances may seek an assessment and begin appropriate treatment.

Each activity produces different kinds of records.

Educational programs provide completion records and certificates. Employment searches produce applications and correspondence. Treatment providers maintain attendance and clinical records.

Those materials document what actually occurred.

They may also provide a foundation for future employment, financial stability, and personal development.

Now imagine that your federal investigation continues for 18 months.

At the end of that period, you've completed a professional certification, established new employment, and maintained accurate records of your work.

Those accomplishments exist regardless of whether the government files charges.

If the case later reaches sentencing, your attorney can evaluate whether some of that information is relevant to the court.

A statement describing the intention to find employment cannot establish the same history as 18 months of actual work.

Why Prepare a Personal Narrative Before Sentencing?

A personal narrative is a written account of a person's background, circumstances, experiences, and, where appropriate, the conduct involved in a criminal case.

It may become relevant when someone has pleaded guilty or been convicted and is preparing for sentencing.

A narrative can give counsel additional information about the person beyond the allegations described in the charging documents.

For example, the court may need to understand an individual's employment history, medical circumstances, family responsibilities, or activities undertaken after an offense.

A defendant who has accepted responsibility may explain the decisions involved in the offense and the work completed afterward.

Someone maintaining innocence requires an approach consistent with that legal position.

The document should reflect the actual circumstances of the case.

In an educational interview with Michael Santos, former federal Chief Judge Mark W. Bennett discussed the possibility of a defendant developing a personal narrative before the presentence investigation report was completed.

Michael asked whether preparing the narrative earlier could allow the probation officer to consider the information while assembling the report.

Judge Bennett responded favorably, explaining that he would be impressed to learn that a defendant had undertaken that work before the last minute.

His observations reflected his individual perspective. They do not establish that a narrative will influence every judge or probation officer.

But consider the practical situation.

Suppose you have spent two years involved in a federal case. Your lawyer tells you the probation interview is scheduled for next month.

Could you provide an accurate account of your employment, education, medical history, finances, and relevant activities during those two years?

Do you have the supporting records?

If you've completed legitimate treatment, professional training, or other work, those records already exist.

You don't have to begin reconstructing the entire period shortly before sentencing.

Any written narrative concerning the allegations should be developed with your attorney's guidance, particularly during an active investigation.

What Does a Federal Judge Think About Remorse?

In another educational interview, Judge Stephen R. Bough of the Western District of Missouri discussed how he evaluated expressions of remorse.

Michael Santos asked about the weight a judge might place on a defense attorney's statement that a defendant was remorseful.

Judge Bough emphasized the difference between an apology and conduct demonstrating that the person had considered the consequences of an offense.

He used the example of a child who breaks a window with a baseball.

The child can apologize, but the response to the broken window may provide additional information about whether the child understands and accepts responsibility for what happened.

The example is relevant to people who have admitted criminal conduct.

If you have pleaded guilty, what have you done since the offense?

Have you addressed the circumstances that contributed to your decisions? Are there genuine financial obligations or personal problems you've begun resolving?

Can you identify completed work rather than simply describing what you intend to do after sentencing?

A defendant contesting criminal allegations should not be pressured to express remorse for conduct they deny.

But the broader question about documented conduct applies to many circumstances.

How does someone evaluating your record distinguish promises from work you've actually completed?

That distinction becomes easier when there are accurate records created over a sustained period.

How Could Your Presentence Investigation Report Affect You?

If your case leads to a conviction, a federal probation officer ordinarily prepares a presentence investigation report, commonly called the PSR.

The report can contain information about the offense, criminal history, financial circumstances, employment, family, education, health, and other factors relevant to sentencing.

Your lawyer can explain how the process works, what information is required, and how to review the completed report for errors.

The PSR may also follow someone into federal custody.

During an educational interview with Michael Santos, federal probation professional Chris Maloney discussed the importance of developing an accurate picture of the person being sentenced.

He also explained that the Bureau of Prisons uses information from presentence reports in decisions involving classification, designation, and programming.

An inaccurate employment history, medical record, or description of substance use can therefore have implications beyond the sentencing hearing.

Suppose your report says you have no relevant medical history, even though you have been receiving treatment for a documented condition.

Or imagine the report incorrectly describes your educational background or employment.

These are factual issues that deserve attention during the report review process.

The appropriate information must be supported and accurate.

Someone still under investigation should not assume a presentence report will ever be necessary. But knowing how one is prepared helps explain why certain records may eventually become useful.

Why Create Book Reports, Journals, and Educational Records?

Michael Santos spent 26 consecutive years in federal prison. During his incarceration, he pursued formal education, wrote books, and documented his activities.

His work provides a practical example of how educational records can accumulate over time.

Consider a person who reads 12 books about business ethics, professional responsibility, or another subject relevant to future employment.

Finishing those books may improve the person's knowledge, but what can they explain about what they learned?

A book report provides an opportunity to answer specific questions.

Why did you choose the book? What did you learn? How can you apply the information to a decision or responsibility in your life?

Suppose you read a book about accounting controls because you intend to work in financial administration.

You might identify a particular control discussed in the book, research how businesses implement it, and use that knowledge in a course or professional project.

Your written report can explain what you studied and how you applied it.

Now compare that with a document containing only a list of book titles.

Which provides more useful information about your actual learning?

The same principle applies to journals and other written records.

A journal can describe educational progress, completed projects, employment activities, or other accomplishments.

During an active criminal investigation, writing about disputed conduct, potential witnesses, or allegations requires particular caution. Discuss that material and any intended publication with your attorney.

The goal of educational documentation is to preserve a truthful account of useful work.

A journal that contains repeated promises about becoming a better person without any corresponding activity offers very little.

What Does a Release Plan Show?

A release plan becomes relevant when someone is preparing for sentencing or an eventual return from federal custody.

The plan can address housing, employment, financial obligations, medical care, treatment, and other responsibilities.

But many of those subjects can be considered before sentencing.

Suppose you've lost your professional license and cannot return to your former career.

What occupation might be available to you after the case concludes?

Do you need additional training? Have you researched licensing restrictions? Have you identified employers or businesses where your existing skills might be useful?

If you're facing substantial financial obligations, what income can you realistically earn? What expenses will you need to cover?

If you need continuing treatment, have you identified providers and maintained accurate medical records?

These questions require specific answers.

A plan that says you intend to return to work is incomplete if you no longer hold the credentials required for your previous occupation.

A more useful plan identifies realistic opportunities and the steps already taken to pursue them.

A person who begins that work before sentencing may have completed certifications, developed professional relationships, or secured employment opportunities by the time the court reviews the case.

Those accomplishments may be relevant to counsel's presentation. They may also improve the person's circumstances independently of any sentencing decision.

Who Should Write a Character Reference Letter?

People approaching federal sentencing sometimes believe they need letters from prominent executives, politicians, or other influential individuals.

In Michael Santos's educational interview with Judge Bennett, the judge discussed his interest in letters from people who genuinely knew the defendant, regardless of their professional status.

An employer who worked alongside you for 15 years may be able to describe your responsibilities, accomplishments, and conduct.

A volunteer coordinator could provide specific information about work you've completed.

A family member might describe responsibilities you've maintained through difficult circumstances.

The relationship and firsthand knowledge are more useful than an impressive title alone.

Consider the difference between two letters.

One describes the defendant as an excellent person who deserves leniency.

The other explains that the writer supervised the defendant for several years, identifies specific responsibilities, and describes actual events supporting the writer's assessment.

The second provides information the court can evaluate.

Letters should be accurate, and the writer should understand the relevant circumstances as advised by defense counsel.

If you may eventually need character references, think about the relationships you've maintained.

Who actually knows your work?

Who has observed your responsibilities over time?

Who can describe something you've done rather than simply offer an opinion about your character?

Can Artificial Intelligence Help Create Preparation Materials?

AI tools can help organize information, transcribe interviews, and prepare initial drafts.

They can also produce writing that sounds impressive while saying very little about the individual.

Suppose a defendant asks AI to prepare a personal narrative about remorse and rehabilitation.

The system might produce several polished pages describing personal growth, family commitments, and plans to contribute to society.

But which statements are supported by facts?

Did the person actually complete the educational program mentioned? Was treatment attended? Are the professional achievements accurately described?

Documents prepared for court require careful attention to accuracy, especially where they discuss conduct relevant to the case.

A false or exaggerated assertion could undermine the credibility of the material and create additional problems.

If you use AI to organize personal information, the final document must reflect your actual experiences and records. Sensitive legal information also raises confidentiality and privilege considerations that should be addressed with counsel.

No writing tool can complete six months of treatment or professional coursework for you.

Those activities require your participation.

The resulting records can then be organized and explained accurately.

What Can You Show After Six Months of Preparation?

Imagine two people facing federal investigations involving similar allegations.

Both retain criminal defense lawyers. Both continue cooperating with counsel and following legal advice.

During the next six months, one person spends most of their time waiting for an update and researching possible sentencing outcomes.

The other identifies legitimate professional and personal issues that need attention.

Perhaps they have lost a job and begin working toward a new certification. They complete coursework and document the results.

Maybe they participate in appropriate treatment for an existing problem, maintain employment, or work consistently with a community organization.

At the end of six months, their circumstances may still be uncertain. Neither knows whether prosecutors will bring charges.

But the second person has completed work that can be described and verified.

Those accomplishments do not establish innocence, justify a particular sentence, or guarantee favorable treatment.

They may help the individual find employment, address personal problems, and prepare for responsibilities that continue regardless of the criminal case.

If the case reaches sentencing, defense counsel can evaluate whether any of that work belongs in the materials submitted to the court.

Now consider your own circumstances.

When did you first learn about the investigation?

What have you accomplished since then?

Which activities would you want to continue even if the government told you tomorrow that the investigation had ended without charges?

Those answers can help identify work worth beginning or continuing.

Where Can You Learn More About the Federal Criminal Justice Process?

White Collar Advice provides educational material concerning government investigations, sentencing preparation, personal narratives, presentence reports, and other stages of federal criminal cases.

The team also offers interviewing, preparation, and writing assistance under individual agreements, working alongside defense counsel.

The separate nonprofit Prison Professors provides free educational resources developed through Michael Santos's extensive experience in federal prison and subsequent educational work.

If you're still under investigation, begin with material explaining investigative status, federal criminal procedure, and the decisions that may arise before an indictment.

If your case proceeds toward sentencing, the personal narrative, presentence investigation, character letter, and release planning resources may become relevant.

You can study these subjects through White Collar Advice and Prison Professors.

If you want assistance preparing materials or understanding the preparation services available for your circumstances, you can also schedule a conversation with White Collar Advice.

What Will You Have Created When the Investigation Ends?

You may be six weeks into a federal investigation, or perhaps it's been two years.

You don't know whether prosecutors will bring charges. Your attorney may still be evaluating evidence or discussing the matter with the government.

At some point, the investigation will develop further. Charges may be filed, prosecutors may decline to bring a case, or another decision may change your circumstances.

What will exist at that point that doesn't exist today?

Perhaps it will be a completed professional certification, a documented employment history, or records of legitimate treatment.

Maybe you'll have learned enough about the federal criminal justice system to participate more effectively in discussions with your lawyer.

If you're eventually preparing for sentencing, you may have an accurate record of activities completed over the preceding months instead of trying to reconstruct everything shortly before the hearing.

You cannot determine the government's next decision simply by completing a course, writing a narrative, or preparing a release plan.

But you can examine the work available to you now.

What have you done since learning about the investigation, and what could you reasonably complete over the next six months or 30 minutes?

Written by

Justin Paperny

Founder White Collar Advice